I understand that Pope Benedict XVI recently said that pro-choice politicians should not receive communion because
...the killing of an innocent child is incompatible with receiving communion, which is receiving the body of Christ.
According to the Pope, voting pro-choice is the moral equivalent of killing innocent children.
All right.
My question, then, is whether or not politicians who vote for military spending or to approve the use of military force should receive communion? After all, military action kills innocent children.
What about politicians who support the death penalty? Thought they're not children, innocent people have been put to death in the past. And it's well known that, even with recent advances in DNA testing, there's no guarantee that an executed offender is the guilty party.
Catholic doctrine is opposed not only to abortion, but war and execution as well - even if you don't agree with it, at least they're consistent. And "killing innocent children" is not the only sin that makes one ineligible to receive communion in the Catholic church - so does missing mass on Sunday or any Holy Day of Obligation. And the last time I was in church for the Feast of the Assumption, there were plenty of open seats.
Not that any of this makes much of a difference in the current debate, which really has nothing to do with killing children, and everything to do with political opportunism.